Contested stories of commercial security: self- and media narratives of private military and security companies

Critical Studies on Security

Volume 1, Issue 3, 2013

Contested stories of commercial security: self- and media narratives of private military and security companies

Contested stories of commercial security: self- and media narratives of private military and security companies

DOI:
10.1080/21624887.2013.857467

Andreas Krucka* & Alexander Spencera
pages 326-346

Abstract

The article illustrates the potential of narrative analysis as a transdisciplinary method for Critical Security Studies by investigating self-legitimizing narratives of private military and security companies (PMSCs) and contrasting them to the narratives on PMSCs found in the news media. Employing narrative analysis and focusing on the websites of 55 PMSCs and 4 quality US and British newspapers, we reconstruct how PMSCs and the media establish 4 conflicting narratives characterizing PMSCs as technical and military experts vs. incompetent cowboys, professional businessmen vs. exploiting war profiteers, noble humanitarians vs. uncontrolled abusers and proud patriots vs. dirty mercenaries. Our analysis shows that the self-narratives of the PMSCs largely fail to arrive in the public media narratives, although some self-characterizations such as the expert or the businessman resonate somewhat better than others, in particular the strongly romanticizing images of the humanitarian or the patriot. We propose the concept of ‘intertextual narratability’ to suggest that the media reception of PMSCs’ self-narratives is shaped by their (lack of) connectability to existing culturally embedded narratives on PMSCs.

This entry was posted in Academic and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply